President Obama is threatening Social Security checks may not go out in August because of his dispute with Congress over raising the Debt Ceiling.
As pointed out in yesterday’s Wall Street Journal editorial page, how can this be possible when Social Security has a Trust Fund?  The Social Security Administration (“SSA”) website reports an impressive Trust Fund balance of $2,669,215,081 as of June 30, 2011 . What happened to your money?
Haven’t we been told by the editors of the New York Times, Paul Krugman and others that the Trust Fund is solid as a rock and people are “peddling nonsense” to imply otherwise?
Back in 2005, the New York Times said:
“At a recent press conference, Mr. Bush exaggerated the timing of the system’s shortfall by saying that Social Security would cross the “line into red” in 2018…. If you had a trust fund to pay your bills when your income fell short, would you consider yourself insolvent?”
“In suggesting that 2018 is doomsyear, [Bush] is reinforcing a false impression that the trust fund is a worthless pile of I.O.U.’s – as detractors of Social Security so often claim.” 
Just last year, the Times’ strongly opinionated columnist Paul Krugman opined:
“So where do claims of crisis come from? To a large extent they rely on bad-faith accounting. In particular, they rely on an exercise in three-card monte in which the surpluses Social Security has been running for a quarter-century don’t count — because hey, the program doesn’t have any independent existence; it’s just part of the general federal budget — while future Social Security deficits are unacceptable — because hey, the program has to stand on its own.”
“It would be easy to dismiss this bait-and-switch as obvious nonsense, except for one thing: many influential people — including Alan Simpson, co-chairman of the president’s deficit commission — are peddling this nonsense.” 
How can Mr. Krugman and the New York Times editors square their confidence in the strength of the SSA Trust Fund against President Obama’s “I cannot guarantee that those checks go out on August 3”? Is the President just playing a game or is the Trust Fund really empty?
The possible absence of Social Security checks results from an unusual structure. If you have a private sector pension or 401(k), your retirement funds are set aside in a segregated account and the funds are invested in stocks and bonds.
The Federal Government receives payroll and regular taxes every day and makes accounting entries for Social Security receipts vs. Social Security payouts. SSA built up an excess of payroll tax receipts over payouts as working Baby Boomers paid in for decades. This accounting entry comprises the Trust Funds. 
The issue with August’s Social Security checks is the Trust Fund is not invested like a normal pension. Every dollar of Trust Fund surplus is invested in US Treasury obligations, meaning the Trust Fund was already spent for the general use of the Federal Government.  Despite New York Times claims to the contrary, the SSA Trust Fund holds $2.7 Trillion in IOUs.
US government debt has traditionally been such a safe IOU it was called the “risk-free asset” back when I took Finance classes. Still, even before the current Debt Ceiling controversy, trillion Dollar annual deficits led ratings agencies like Standard & Poor’s in May 2009 to issue warnings about a possible downgrade of US debt. 
Grandma’s Social Security check could be held up not only in August but again in the future after the current Debt Ceiling crisis is settled. The SSA Trust Fund is simply a very large claimant on future tax receipts of the US Treasury. The New York Times misunderstood how safe the Trust Fund supposedly is as we now have the spectacle of an American President threatening Social Security payments may not be made on account of the supposedly separate matter of the federal budget deficit. There is no lockbox; there is no firewall between Social Security and the overall budget. SSA is not quite “separate”; it is linked to the overall fiscal health of the US government.
 pg. A12, 7/16/11 print edition or http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702304521304576446250270069780.html?KEYWORDS=trust+fund
 Technically there are two Trust Funds: Old Age Survivor (retirement) and Disability.